English 2F: Critical Reading and Writing about Cultures (II) --- 2009 Fall

Instruction to Essay I: Visual-verbal Essay

Why to write verbal-visual essay?

For Essay I, students are expected to use creative thinking to describe and analyze a given visual text, based on which they develop ideas with details, examples, or statistics.

Writing process:


Instruction to Essay II: Critical Thinking---Argumentation

As students are becoming more confident in their thinking and writing abilities, they should learn how to evaluate information, how to express their own perspectives clearly and how to persuade and convince readers with their opinions.

Why to argue and persuade?
Our beliefs usually come from four sources: people of authority, recorded references, observed evidence, and personal evidence.

People often continue to believe the same ideas they were brought up with without ever examining and deciding for themselves what to think. Perspectives, or points of view, are what people express when they speak and write and also the vantage points from which they perceive events or issues. So a complex interaction exists between perceptions and perspectives. People's perspectives are formed by beliefs, interests, needs, age, gender, nationality, ethnicity, health, education - the multiple factors of life. These factors of perspective influence perceptions; at the same time, perceptions continuously influence perspective. Various people can be exposed to the same stimuli or events and yet have different perceptions, as if each of us views the world through personal "contact lenses". We are usually aware that we are wearing these lenses. Instead, without our realizing it, our lenses act as filters that select and shape what we perceive. To understand how people perceive the world, we have to understand their individual lenses, which influence how they actively select, organize and interpret the events in their experience.

Effective critical thinkers are aware of the lenses that they - and others - are wearing. People unaware of the nature of their own lenses can often mistake their own perceptions for objective truth, not having examined either the facts or others' perceptions of a given issue.

Instead of simply accepting the views of others, students should gradually develop the ability to identify and evaluate beliefs before accepting them with critical thinking, and, at the same time, they should also know how to persuade readers to accept the well-supported beliefs.

Topic of Essay II:
For Essay II, students are expected to use critical thinking to re-evaluate a belief about education, gender, or culture, which has been accepted by most people as common sense. For example, in Europe before the fifteenth century, the common belief that the earth was flat was supported by the following reasons and evidence:
People of authority: Many educational and religious authorities taught that the earth was flat.
Recorded references: the written opinions of scientific experts supported belief in a flat earth.
Observed evidence: no person had ever circumnavigated the earth.
Personal experience: from a normal vantage point, the earth looks flat.

Why do you think it is a falsifiable belief? How can you convince the readers that the belief is false? with personal experience? through people of authority? Try to find authoritative supports to develop your opinion. The topic should be developed into a 5-7 pages long essay, each point developed in details. Remember description and narration can be supportive techniques to argumentation.

The purpose of this essay:
In this information age, we are flooded with data, stores, and pictures from television, radio, newspapers, magazines, books, and computers. Thus, critical thinkers and thoughtful writers have to face a continuing challenge to evaluate information they receive and to redefine their beliefs accordingly. Therefore, it is very critical to think twice and ask why before believing.

Instruction to Essay III: Research Paper

Writing process

Step 1:Topic selection
Start with some general topics on issues of cultural conflicts (collision), and search for materials on websites and online databases. Based on the results of searching, narrow down to 1 topic, and do further material searching to find out the possibility and feasibility of the topics for research paper.
Online databases: http://www.cwpost.liu.edu/cwis/cwp/library/database.htm
Social Sciences Databases (http://www.cwpost.liu.edu/cwis/cwp/library/database/social.htm)
General Databases (http://www.cwpost.liu.edu/cwis/cwp/library/database/general.htm)

Step 2: Do intensive search for more specific materials for your topic.
Read the collected materials carefully and attentively, while thinking what a specific point your research paper will work on. At this stop you have to restrict your topic to one very specific point. A general topic could only make your 10-page research paper stay at a very shallow level.
You have to write annotation bibliography to each of five materials you are going to cite in your paper. Sample Annotated bibliography

Step 3: Research design
Work out an outline for research paper, with the following aspects:
Research aim: What is your hypothesis of the research? What is the problem you want to solve?
Research methodology:Based on materials or statistics from prior research? Or investigation? Or collecting data through experiment? Survey? Interview? Questionnaire? Or case study?
Structure of research paper
Conclusion

Step 4: Drafting
Outlining and drafting are interwoven with each other, since research design will be revised again and again in the process of drafting. When research paper is finished, it should be accompanied with a well-organized outline, too.
The research paper must be as long as 8-10 pages and should have at least ten reference/bibliography materials, and at least five works cited in the paper. Among five cited works, the sources from internet will be restricted to two. (That means that you can only use two materials from internet, and other 3 should be from other sources, like databases, books, newspapers and magazines, etc.) Make sure all the in-text citation and works cited follow MLA format. Every table, or chart, or diagram should be numbered and attached with proper explanation and source information.

Step 5:Revising and Finishing
To a research paper, peer review will be a great help, since your peer will become your first readers to judge the effectiveness of your conclusions or findings, which proves the value of your research. Combine the peer input and extra proofreading to revise and wrap up the research paper.

Instruction to Essay IV: Literary Analysis & Creative Writing

Literary Analysis

A literary critical analysis explains a work of fiction, poetry or drama by means of interpretations. The goal of a literary analysis (as with any other analysis) is to broaden and deepen your understanding of a work of literature and share with readers some insights about the work. In a literary analysis your thesis and supporting evidence grow directly out of your reading of the text. All you have to do is select the textual evidence that supports your thesis.

By examining both what the author says and how he or she expresses it, you increase your readers' understandingand appreciation of the work. And, close textual analysis develops your ability to think critically and independently. Studying literature also strengthens your own writing.

As you examine literary work, you become familiar with the strategies that skilled writers use to convey meaning with eloquence and power. It also becomes the basis for you to start your own creative writing.

How to write a literary analysis

Therefore, the heart of the essay should be a discussion of the literary devices used by the author to express that theme. This should be done by a close examination of specific examples from the text.

Creative Writing
Creative writing is anything where the purpose is to express thoughts, feelings and emotions rather than to simply convey information. creative writing. Creative fiction (mainly short stories and novels), poetry, (auto)biography and creative non-fiction are all forms of creative writing.

"Creative writing is writing that expresses the writer's thoughts and feelings in an imaginative, often unique, and poetic way." (Sil.org "What is Creative Writing?")

"Writing is a form of personal freedom. It frees us from the mass identity we see all around us. In the end, writers will write not to be outlaw heroes of some underculture but mainly to save themselves, to survive as individuals." (Don DeLillo)

Writing of any sort is hard, but rewarding work --- you'll gain a huge amount of satisfaction from a finished piece. Being creative can also be difficult and challenging at times, but immensely fun.

For Essay IV, you can either choose a literary work to write a literary analysis, or try a creative writing by yourself. Remember starting small. Have a go at a short story or a poem.