This collection consists of three archival documents, which offer a piece of the case the Vice Admiralty built against Caverley. The testimony of an eye witness to Caverley's criminal acts is found in the examination of Jonathan Brodrick, who survived capture by Caverly, Palgrave Williams, Caverley's boss and captain of the pirate vessel Mary Anne, and Higgins. Secondly, former underlings of Caverley, John Russell and James Vine seek a pardon from the Vice Admiralty for the "error of their ways" in the Petition document. The last item is the arrest warrant for the pirate Richard Caverley, which includes a physical description for the officers of the law to better acquaint themselves with the criminal.